The Weirdest Rules in Sports: Wait… THAT’S a Rule?
Sports have rules for just about everything — but some of them are so strange, obscure, or downright confusing that even longtime fans might not know they exist.
In this episode of True Fan True Opinions, we’re digging into some of the weirdest rules in sports. From bizarre technicalities and little-known loopholes to rules that make you stop and say, “Wait… That’s a rule?”
Which ones actually make sense? Which are completely ridiculous? And how many of these did we have no idea existed?
Join us for another fan-first sports conversation as we debate the strange side of the rulebook.
True Fan True Opinions — Let’s talk sports like fans do.
Don't miss an episode! Please subscribe, leave a comment and share with a sports friend.
Let's talk sports, like fans do!
00:00 - Opening: The Weirdest Rules in Sports - Wait... THAT's a Rule?
00:49 - Wait... Why is THAT a Rule?
06:47 - You can't wear THAT!
11:02 - You did WHAT? That's a Penalty?!
18:01 - The Clock, Score & Technicality Rules
21:06 - Yes. That's Actually a Sport... and THAT'S Actually a Rule
26:54 - Wait... THAT Used to Be a Rule?!
31:44 - Believe It or Bullshit? Weird Rules Edition
36:13 - Sue's True Moment
40:24 - TFTO Closing & Signoff
Opening: The Weirdest Rules in Sports - Wait... THAT's a Rule?
SueBeing a true sports fan means knowing your team, knowing the players, and of course, knowing the rules. Or at least we think we know the rules. Because have you ever been watching a game when something happens, the whistle blows, the officials make the call, and you're sitting there thinking, wait, what? That's a rule? And suddenly a play changes, a run counts, a goal doesn't, maybe even a game turns because of some rule you didn't even know existed. And trust me, there are some weird ones. Welcome back and thank you for joining me today. This is going to be such a fun episode. I'm so looking forward to it. So let's talk sports like fans
Wait... Why is THAT a Rule?
Suedo. I understand why sports need rules, obviously. But sometimes I read one and my first question isn't what does this rule mean? It's what the hell happened that somebody actually had to write this rule. And sometimes the answer is something nobody could have predicted until it actually happened. Like for instance, Pat Vendiet. Back in 2008, Vendiet was pitching in the New York Yankees minor league system. But here's what made him different. He could pitch with both hands. He even had this specially made glove that he could wear on either hand. So one night, Vendiet is on the mound and up comes Ralph Henriquez. And Henriquez is a switch hitter. You can probably see where this is going. Vendit gets ready to pitch right-handed. Henriquez switches sides so he can bat left-handed. So Vendit goes, okay, I'll pitch left-handed and switches his glove. Henriquez sees that and switches sides again. So Vendit switches again. Henriquez switches again. And they just keep going back and forth, back and forth. And everybody watching is probably thinking, what exactly is going on here? And the poor umpires are basically standing there trying to figure out how they're supposed to end this thing. Eventually they did, and shortly after that, baseball basically said, Okay, apparently we need a rule for this. The pitcher has to declare which hand he's gonna use first. Then the switch hitter gets to choose which side he's going to bat from. And that's what makes this one so great for me. Neither guy was cheating, neither guy was really doing anything wrong. They just found a situation that apparently nobody had thought to put in a rule book yet until Pat Van D came along. And then there's hockey. And if you're a hockey fan, you probably know the name Roger Nielsen. Hell of a great coach. Roger Nielsen was one of the greatest, well, technically the rule doesn't say I can't do it, guys in sports. He studied the rule book, and if there was a loophole in there, Roger was gonna find it. One of my favorites involved penalty shots. At the time, Nielsen realized the rules didn't specifically require a goaltender to defend one. So he put a defenseman in net. And instead of waiting for the shooter like a goalie normally would, the defenseman could charge out towards him and take away his space. Seriously. And then there was his solution to protecting a lead late in the game. Nielsen realized that if his team deliberately put too many men on the ice, yeah, they'll get a penalty, but they also get a whistle. So he'll send extra players over the boards to stop the play. And if the punishment isn't bad enough to stop you from doing it, well, Roger Nielsen was apparently going to keep doing it. So eventually the NHL had to close these kinds of loopholes. And that's my favorite part of the whole Roger Nielsen story. He wasn't necessarily breaking the rules. He was basically looking at the officials and saying, show me where it says I can't do this. And apparently the NHL eventually went, fine Roger, we'll put it in there. So here's another one, and this one is bonkers. 1994, Barbados versus Granada in the Caribbean Cup. Barbados needed to win the game by two goals to advance. Okay, normal enough. Except this tournament had one very strange rule. If the game was tied after regulation, it went to extra time. And if you scored the golden goal in extra time, it counted as two goals. What? Alright, that's a little different. Okay, so Barbados had been leading 2-0. Granada scored. Now it's 2-1. And Barbados needed two-goal victory. They try to score again, can't do it, and time is running out. So in the 87th minute, Barbados comes up with a solution that makes absolutely no sense until you understand this ridiculous rule. They intentionally score on themselves. Now it's 2-2. Because if they keep it tied and get to extra time, they get another chance to score one golden goal, which would count as two. Except Granada figures out what they're doing and Granada realizes something else. They don't actually care which goal they score in. If Granada scores normally, Barbados doesn't get what they need. But if Granada scores on their own goal and gives Barbados a one-goal win, Barbados still doesn't get the two-goal margin they need. So now we have one of the most ridiculous endings to a soccer game you could possibly imagine. You got Granada trying to score in either net, and Barbados is defending both of them. So for the final few minutes, Barbados is basically has two goals to protect. They somehow pull it off, the game goes to extra time, Barbados scores the golden goal. And under this bizarre rule, they win four to two in advance. I mean, come on. If your rule results in one team intentionally scoring on itself, then the other team trying to score on both sides of the field while the first team is defending both goals, I'm going to say you probably got a problem with your rule. And that's exactly why I love these stories. Sometimes you read a weird rule and think, why would they ever need that? Well, sometimes the answer is because somebody actually did it.
You can't wear THAT!
SueLet's talk about dress codes. Because we're not talking about whether you can play the game. Sometimes we're talking about whether you're wearing the right clothes. You have the right equipment. Apparently, even the right underwear. Come on. So let's start with chess. Now, whether chess is an actual sport, that's a whole nother debate. Actually, I think I just found my future episode. But regardless, competitive chess does have dress codes. And one Canadian grandmaster found that out in a very public way. At the 2017 Chess World Cup, Anton Kavarov showed up for his third round match wearing shorts. That's it, shorts. He actually worn shorts earlier in the tournament too. But this time the chief arbiter told him his clothing didn't comply with the dress requirements and asked him to change. Then things got ugly. Kavaroff had a separate confrontation with one of the organizers and left the venue and never came back for his match. So eventually, he lost by forfeit. Now, I want to be fair here. He wasn't disqualified because somebody saw his bare legs. There's more to the story than that. But I still can't get over the fact that we're at a chess World Cup. And part of the controversy is shorts. You're sitting across from somebody who can probably calculate 20 moves ahead, and we're talking about what they're wearing below the knees? Come on. Now let's go from chess to Formula One. Formula One drivers are flying around a track at ridiculous speeds. And apparently somebody also has to make sure they're wearing the correct underwear. Seriously. The FIA have safety requirements covering the protective clothing drivers wear underneath their racing suits. We're talking underwear, socks, shirts, the whole thing has to meet specific fire resistance safety standards. And my first reaction was wait, Formula One has rules about underwear? But then you think about it fire, heat, a driver trapped inside a race car after a crash, and suddenly I'm going, yeah, right, okay, I actually get this one. Still, it's pretty funny that there's an underwear rule, but okay, I get it. And then there's tennis. You're in the middle of this incredible rally, right? Back and forth, back and forth. And suddenly your opponent's hat falls off. Now we've potentially got a hindrance issue. Because tennis rules allow for a point to be replayed when a player is unintentionally hindered by something outside their control. So now, in the middle of this great tennis match, an official may have to deal with whether a hat interfered with the point. And I'm sorry, if I'm the opponent, that hat distracted me. Absolutely, 100%. I saw nothing but the hat. And finally, gymnastics. Because apparently dress codes can get right down to your bra strap. Under USA gymnastic rules, there are guidelines covering exposed undergarments and even acceptable bra strap colors. Black, clear, skin tone, or matching the Leotard. And inappropriate attire can potentially lead to a warning and a deduction. What? Hold on. You're flipping through the air, landing on a four-inch beam, you stick the landing, and we're talking about your bra strap? What? But here's the part I actually love. USA Gymnastics guidance recognizes that sometimes a bra strap becomes visible simply because, well, she's doing gymnastics. And the guidance essentially says, use some common sense. Yes, thank you. Because if somebody just flipped through the air, landed on four inches of wood, and somehow stayed upright, maybe we don't need to ruin her day because her bra strap moved.
You did WHAT? That's a Penalty?!
SueI've watched sports my entire life. And some of these next rules, if they happen right in front of me, there is zero chance I would know what the ruling was. So let's start with golf. A sport I personally love and hate when I'm playing it. Imagine you're taking your swing. Your club head comes off during your back swing. You keep going, you swing now the headless shaft and completely miss the ball. Does that count as a stroke? Nope. Okay. Now let's change one thing. Your club head comes off during your downswing. You finish a swing with the headless shaft, completely miss the ball again, and this time? Yep, it counts as a stroke. What? And apparently, if the club head flies off during that downswing and the detached club head itself actually hits the ball, yep, still a stroke. Okay, so apparently the difference between a stroke and not a stroke could come down to whether my club falls apart on this side of my swing or that side of my swing. Who came up with this? Although, knowing my golf game, my club falling apart might actually improve my score. Now let's go to dressage. Under the current equestrian Canadian rules, repeatedly using your voice or clicking your tongue is considered a serious fault and could affect the mark for the movement. So let me get this right. You're riding a horse, a thousand-plus pound animal, you're trying to get this horse to perform incredible precise movements. And one of the things you're specifically not supposed to rely on is come on, good boy. I'm controlling this enormous horse, and you're telling me I can't even click my tongue? Are you serious? But once I understood why, this one actually makes a little more sense. Part of the whole point of dressage is that the communication between the rider and horse is supposed to look almost invisible. The movements are supposed to appear effortless. So loudly talking to your horse or repeatedly clicking away kind of defeats the point. Still, if I was the rider, yeah, I'll probably be eliminated in about 30 seconds. And now baseball. And apparently, if you're an outfielder and you can't reach the ball, don't get creative and throw your hat at it. Seriously. Imagine you're in the outfield, ball is hit your way. You can't quite reach it. So you're thinking, I got an idea. You take off your hat and throw it at the baseball. So if you deliberately use your detached hat or another part of your uniform or equipment to touch a fair batted ball, the other team gets three bases. Three! And there's an important distinction here. If your hat simply falls off and the baseball happens to hit it, that's not automatically three bases. You have to deliberately use the detached equipment to touch the ball. I honestly don't know if I ever seen this happen. But I would love to see it. Not even because of the rule. I want to see the manager's face after one of his outfielders decides, can't reach it. I'm just gonna throw my hat at it. How about water polo? You're playing water polo. You're surrounded by water, and you're telling me there's a rule against splashing? Come on, seriously? Is this for real? Yeah, it is. But the important distinction is that we're talking about intentionally splashing water into an opponent's face to interfere with them. Not just, you know, water splashing around while people are playing water polo. So okay, when you explain it that way, I get it. But I still love that somewhere in water polo rulebook, they basically had to say, hey you, stop splashing. And finally, this tennis rule is one I actually think is pretty cool. Tennis fans know that normally you can't reach across the net and hit the ball before it comes over to your side, right? Except apparently sometimes you can. Say your opponent hits a shot with so much backspin that the ball lands on your side of the court first, then spins back over the net onto their side. At that point, you're allowed to reach across the net and play the ball. Obviously, you still can't just touch the net or do whatever the hell you want, but in that specific situation, you can reach over, and honestly, I don't think this one's stupid. I think it's awesome. I would love to see that happen in a match. Because if somebody puts that much backspin on a tennis ball and the other player somehow reaches across and hit the ball without touching the net, I'm not even thinking about the rule anymore. I'm applauding both of them. Some rules are weird because of what happened. Others are weird because of some tiny technicality that can completely change the play. And you know the kind. So you didn't actually beat them because of what happened on the field. You beat them because somebody didn't understand rule eight, section four, paragraph three. Alright, come on. Like in rhythmic gymnastics. Alright, so imagine you're in the middle of your routine, you throw your hoop into the air, and it gets stuck in the ceiling. What do you do? Well, apparently the rule book has a plan for this. And you don't get to say, well, obviously that wasn't supposed to happen. Can I start again? Nope, no do-overs. You can grab a replacement hoop and keep going. And the wild part is that rhythmic gymnastic rules actually account for hoops and equipment getting caught overhead. I didn't even know this was something you needed a rule for. But apparently somebody somewhere has thrown the hoop just a little too high. Here's something I definitely never really thought about. What happens if a baseball gets stuck in the umpire's mask? I've seen baseballs get caught up in catcher's equipment before, but the umpire? Apparently Major League Baseball had thought about that too, because yes, there's a rule for it. If a pitch ball lodges in the catcher or umpire's equipment and stays out of play, the ball is dead. And the runners advance one base. And I know technically the officials still have to determine that the ball is actually lodged and out of play. But come on. If the baseball is wedged in the umpire's mask, I'm hoping this isn't one of the harder calls he has to make. Hmm. Is that ball generally stuck? Buddy, it's in your face.
The Clock, Score & Technicality Rules
SueOkay, back to the sport I hate. I mean I love golf. Explain this one to me. I shoot a five on a hole, but I accidentally write down six. Too bad, Sue. Congratulations. You just gave yourself an extra stroke. But I shoot a five and I write down four. Now we got a much bigger problem. I can be disqualified. What? And if you think this is just some silly technical rule that never actually mattered, ask Roberto DiVicienso. At the 1968 Masters, his marker, Tommy Aaron, wrote down a four on the 17th hole instead of Roberto's actual three. Di Vicenso signed the card without catching the mistake. And because the score he submitted was higher than what he actually shot, the higher score stood. That cost him a tie with Bob Golby and a playoff for the Masters Championship. Golbi won by one. And Roberto's famous reaction afterward, what a stupid I am. I mean, I can't make this stuff up. Imagine playing well enough to potentially win the Masters and then losing your chance because of the scorecard. I would never recover from that. And now football. This is one of those rules that football fans have probably seen happen, but every single time it does, I still think, why? Here's the situation. Your team is driving towards the opponent's end zone. A player is fighting for extra yards near the goal line and loses the football. If that ball goes out of bounds in the regular field of play, the offense can retain possession under the normal fumble rules. Okay. But if that same fumble goes forward, rolls through the opponent's end zone, and goes out, the other team gets the football. Touchback. Wait, what? The defense didn't recover it. They didn't intercept it, they didn't pick it up. The ball just went out of bounds. And now it's theirs. That's the part I never understood. If I fumble the ball out at the one yard line, my team keeps the ball. But the same ball rolls a few more feet and goes through the end zone, and suddenly you get it? Even though you never recovered it? Come on. I understand there has to be a rule for what happens when the ball goes through the end zone, but given possession to the defense when they never actually got possession, that one still feels harsh to me. And that's exactly why these technicality rules drive fans crazy. Sometimes the smallest detail doesn't just change a play, it changes who gets the ball, who gets the point, or even who wins.
Yes. That's Actually a Sport... and THAT'S Actually a Rule
SueOkay, I'm going to admit something before we start this next segment. We're leaving my sports comfort zone a little bit here. I don't watch a lot of cricket. Actually, I don't really watch cricket. I've watched curling, especially during the Olympics, but I'm definitely not sitting here pretending I know every rule. Racewalking, nope. Sumo? Nope. Table tennis? I played it. And apparently I've been playing it wrong. So some of these rules, I was learning them right along with you. Let's start with cricket. And I'll admit it, when I read this one, I actually checked it again because I thought somebody was messing with me. So at the 2023 Cricket World Cup, Angelo Matthews of Sri Lanka came in to bat against Baldo Dash. Under the tournament rules, an incoming batter has to be ready to face the Next ball within two minutes. Matthews wasn't. Bagledash appealed. And he was called timed out. He became the first batter in international cricket history to be dismissed that way. And here's where it gets even crazier. He never faced a single ball. What? Wait, you can come into a game, not face one ball, and you're already out? There was controversy because Matthews had a problem with his helmet straw and argued that was responsible for the delay. But officials said he had already gone beyond the two-minute limit before the helmet issue happened. Now, I'm not gonna sit here pretending I know enough about cricket to argue whether the call was right or wrong. But I do know this. If I'm a batter and my day ends before anybody even throws me a ball, I'm pissed. Now curling. This one feels so incredibly curling. If you accidentally touch a moving stone with your broom, your body, or your equipment, you can have what's known as a burn stone. And depending on when it happens, the rules can give the non-offending team options for what happens next, including placing stones where they reasonably believe they would have ended up if the violation hadn't happened. Wait, the other team gets a say? So I accidentally touched the rock, and now you're telling me where you think everything would have ended up? Oh come on. I'd be standing there going, no no no no, that rock was definitely going over there, and then they're going, absolutely not, Sue. I'll be arguing about that for the rest of the end. Although that's probably why I shouldn't be curling. Now race walking. And this rule fascinates me. One of the basic rules is that the walker has to maintain contact with the ground, with no loss of contact visible to the human eye. And that's the last part is what got me. Visible to the human eye. Because you know it's 2026. We have cameras that can show me whether somebody's toe was offside. We can just slow things down until we're basically examining individual blades of grass. But Race Walking says human eye. So I'm reading this thinking, hold on, we have slow motion cameras, but if the judge can't actually see you lose contact, you're okay? Apparently, yes. I'm not even saying that's wrong. I just love that in a world where sports are becoming more and more obsessed with technology, racewalking is basically going, nah, we'll use these and these. I'm pointing to my eyes. Okay, sumo. I'm just gonna say this right now. If your entire match depends on nothing staying tied, I'm double knotting it. So the garment sumo wrestlers wear around their waist is called mowashi. And yes, there's rules about it, including the rather important fact that if the mowashi comes completely undone and comes off during the match, you can lose. Now, I'm sure there's a proper way of tying one of those things, and I'm sure sumo wrestlers know exactly what they're doing. Me? I'll be backstage before every match going, can somebody check this again? Are you sure? Pull it tighter. No, tighter than that. Because losing a match is one thing. Losing because your uniform came off, that's a whole different kind of bad day. And finally, table tennis. Or as I've called it basically my entire life, ping pong. I've played this, a lot of us have played this. Basement, garage, rec room, on vacation, wherever there's a table, against friends, family. And apparently we've probably been serving wrong all this time. Because an official table tennis serve isn't just okay, I got the ball, here you go. Nope. The ball has to start resting freely on an open palm. It has to be visible. Then you have to toss it upward, at least 16 centimeters, without putting a spin on it with your hand and hit it as it's coming back down. 16 centimeters. Who's measuring this? Because I can guarantee you that when I was playing ping pong, I wasn't standing there thinking, okay, Sue, open palm, visible ball, 16 centimeters. No, definitely not. I was trying to serve that thing so my buddy couldn't return it. So after researching this episode, I've learned something important. Apparently, I've been playing table tennis wrong my entire life. And I'm guessing I'm not the only one.
Wait... THAT Used to Be a Rule?!
SueEvery sport has rules, and obviously, rules evolve over time. Sometimes the sport changes, sometimes somebody finds a loophole, and sometimes you look back at an old rule and think, who thought that was a good idea? Because some of these old rules were just, well, ridiculous. So let's start with Australian football. Imagine this. It's the grand finale, the championship game. The game ends tied. Okay, overtime, right? Nope, wrong. Everybody, they go home. They come back next Saturday and play the entire grand finale again. What? That was an actual rule. And it wasn't just some bizarre rule sitting in a dusty rule book that never got used. It happened three times. 1948, 1949, and most recently in 2010, when Collingwood and St. Kilda finished the grand finale tied. So after an entire championship game, they basically said, Well, we didn't figure anything out, so see everybody next week. And they played the whole thing again. Can you imagine this happening today? Super Bowl ends tied. Okay, Chiefs, Bills, see you guys next Sunday. Stanley Cup final game seven ends in a tie? Everybody go home. We'll try this again next week. Come on, that's just ridiculous. Thankfully, the AFL eventually got rid of the grand finale replay. Now a tied grand finale goes to extra time, and if they're still tied, they keep playing additional periods until somebody finally wins. You know, like a championship game. Now here's something you could get away with in 1978 that you definitely couldn't get away with today. Football. The Raiders are playing the Chargers. Final seconds. Oakland is losing. Quarterback Ken Stabler is about to be taken down. And Stabler sends the football forward along the ground towards the end zone. Then another Raider helps the ball farther downfield, and eventually Dave Casper falls on it in the end zone. Touchdown. Raiders win. And everybody else basically goes, oh come on. The play became known as the holy roller. And Stabler later acknowledged that yes, he deliberately sent the ball forward. Now think about how ridiculous this looks. The quarterback can't get the ball into the end zone normally. So suddenly we basically got players pushing and kicking, rolling this loose football towards the goal line. And at the time, the touchdown counted. Well, the NFL apparently watched that and went, yeah, we're not doing that again. So the rule was changed. Today on fourth down, or during the final two minutes at half, if an offensive player fumbles, only that player can recover and advance his own fumble. A teammate can recover it, but he can't just keep advancing it towards the end zone. And that is why you can't pull another holy roller today. One crazy play, and suddenly there's a new rule. And finally, Wilt Chamberlain. Imagine being so dominant, so ridiculously athletic, that basketball basically starts looking at you and saying, okay, we're gonna have to change some rules. Will's dominance was associated with several changes in basketball. The lane was widened, there were changes involving offensive goaltending, inbounding, but my favorite for this episode? Free throws. Because Will was athletic enough that there was concern he could take a running start from behind the free throw line, launch himself towards the basket, and basically deposit the ball into the hoop instead of taking a normal free throw. Wait, what? Imagine standing there watching the 7'1 man getting ready for a free throw, and instead of shooting it, he starts running at the basket. No, absolutely not. That's ridiculous. So basketball tighten the free throw rules. The shooter can't cross the vertical plane of the free throw line until the ball touches the rim or backboard or the free throw ends. And I love this one because we're talking about somebody finding some obscured technicality. We're talking about one of the most dominant players in basketball history being such a physical freak that the sport essentially had to say, Wilt, you can't do that anymore. That's when you know you're good. Not when somebody retires your number, not when they build a statue, when somebody has to open the rule book because of you.
Believe It or Bullshit? Weird Rules Edition
SueOkay, after everything we've talked about in this episode, I'm not sure any rule sounds too ridiculous anymore. So let's find out. Let's have some fun. I got six more rules. Three are completely real and three are complete bullshit. I'll give you the rule, you make your guess, and then I'll tell you whether you should believe it or bullshit. So let's go. Number one, tennis. Your opponent hits a ball that's obviously going out, and I mean way out. Instead of letting it bounce, you catch it before it lands. Believe it or bullshit, you lose the point. Got your answer? Believe it. That's a real rule. If the ball is still in play and you catch it before it lands, you've touch a live ball. You lose the point. It doesn't matter if that thing was heading 15 feet out of bounds into the third row. Come on. I'm just trying to catch the thing so it doesn't hit somebody. Nope. Your opponent gets the point. Lesson learned, let it go. Number two, soccer. If identical twins are playing for the same team in an international soccer match, they're required to wear different colored cleats so the referee can tell them apart. Believe it or bullshit. Bullshit, completely made up. There's no special identical twin cleat rule. Although, I gotta admit, it sounds like one of those bizarre little rules somebody would have created after a referee spent 90 minutes going, wait, which twin did that? Okay, number three, another tennis. So a player's grunt can be ruled a hindrance if it reaches a hundred decibels, and the player can lose the point. Believe it or bullshit? Yep, bullshit, total BS. Now, tennis does have rules dealing with hindrance and noise. But there's no official, wait, that grunt hit a hundred disciples point pounty rule. Although maybe there should be. Have you heard some of these matches? Number four. Okay hockey fans, let's see if you know this one. During an NHL video review, the skaters are required to proceed immediately to their respective benches. And if a player refuses to leave the ice, they could receive a game misconduct. Believe it or bullshit? I would have said bullshit, and I'm a hockey fan, but believe it, it's real. How did I not know this? I've watched how many NHL games in my life? And apparently there's a potential game misconduct attached to refusing to go to the bench during a video review. Okay, I learned something new today. Number five, chess boxing. First of all, yes, chess boxing is a real thing. Competitors alternate between round of boxing and chess. But here's the rule. Even if you're doing great in the boxing ring, if your chess clock expires, you can lose the entire match. Believe it or bullshit. Believe it, it's real. You can be the toughest guy in the building, absolutely beating the crap out of somebody in the boxing portion of it, then sit down at the chessboard, run out of time, and lose. Imagine explaining that afterwards to your friends, to your buddies. Hey, how do you lose that fight? Well, Queen's Gambit. I love sports. Number six, last one. And because it's golf, honestly, anything is possible. So if your shadow falls across another player's putting line while they're addressing the ball, you're assessed a one-stroke penalty for interference. Believe it or bullshit. Bullshit. And I'm not gonna lie, I really thought this one was real. Because, you know, it's golf. After everything I've learned about golf rules in this episode, somebody telling me, Sue, your shadow interfered with her putt. One stroke penalty. I'll probably go, yeah, that sounds about right. But nope. No automatic one-stroke penalty just because your shadow falls across somebody's putting line. And that is probably the perfect place to end this game. Because after researching this episode, I'm not sure I know what sounds more ridiculous anymore. The bullshit rules or the ones that are actually real.
Sue's True Moment
SueA few weeks ago, I was watching the Blue Jays and the Red Sox game, and honestly, that game is part of the reason why I wanted to do this episode. Because of course, it happened in the seventh inning, and apparently weird things happened to the Blue Jays in the seventh innings. Boston hits a fly ball. Some of the Red Sox players seem to forget how many outs there are. Toronto doubles the runner off at first base because he didn't tag up. That's three outs. Great. Inning over. Jays are coming off the field. Commercial break. And I'm sitting there thinking, okay, bottom of the seventh. Except we come back from commercial and everybody's still talking. The coaches are talking, the entire umpire and crew is talking. Even the broadcasters are basically going, what is going on? What are they talking about? Then there's a review. They're getting help from New York. And I'm sitting at home going, what the actual fuck is happening? Apparently, we're now talking about a fourth out. I'm sorry. Baseball has three outs. I've watched baseball for more than 40 years. What do you mean, fourth out? And it all had to do with the runner who had cross-home play without properly tagging up. Toronto needed to make the proper appeal at third base so that out could replace the previous third out and prevent the run from counting. And I'm watching all this thinking, how can I have watched this much baseball in my life and still have moments where I have absolutely no idea what the hell is going on? And then it hit me. I felt this before because suddenly I was right back in another seventh inning. October 14th, 2015. Blue Jays, Rangers, game five of the ALDS. And if you're a Jays fan, you know exactly where I'm going. Russell Martin throws the ball back to Aaron Sanchez. It hits Chin Su Shu's bat. Odora comes home. The umpire initially calls the ball dead. Then the umpires get together and the run counts. And Roger Center, it loses its mind. The Jays are arguing, the game is protested, fans are furious, garbage starts coming onto the field, and no, that was definitely not one of our finer moments as a fan base. But the entire stadium feels like it's ready to explode. And that's only the top of the seventh. Then comes the bottom, and Texas makes error after error after error, and you can just feel the entire game changing. The Jays load the bases. Josh Donaldson ties it. And then my man Jose Batista walks to the plate. One swing. It's a three-run home run. And then the bat flip. I could still picture it. I can still hear the crowd. I can still remember what it felt like watching that inning. 53 minutes, arguments, errors, a protest, fans losing their minds, the benches clearing. One of the strangest baseball rulings I've ever seen. Followed by one of the greatest moments I've ever experienced as a Blue Jay fan. What an inning, what a moment. And that's what I kept thinking about while I was researching this episode. We make fun of some of these rules. And honestly, some of them deserve to be made fun of. But I understand why sports need them. Rules are there to create fairness, to protect players, to give everybody some kind of structure so that skill and not complete chaos decides who wins. Well, at least that's the idea. Because sports don't always cooperate. Sometimes something happens that nobody expected. Sometimes somebody finds a loophole. Sometimes a rule nobody knew existed suddenly becomes the biggest thing in the game. And sometimes, 40 plus years into watching a sport you love, you can still sit on your couch and say, wait, that's a rule? And maybe that's part of why I still love sports. Because after all these years, they can still surprise the hell out of me.
TFTO Closing & Signoff
SueThanks so much for listening to another episode of True Fan True Opinion. If you enjoyed today's conversation, I really appreciate it if you follow the show, leave a review, and share it with another sports fan. And don't forget, I want to hear your thoughts. Did you agree with my takes? Did I miss something? Let me know in the comments or on social media. Until next time, keep sharing, keep believing, and remember chin up, don't give up. I'm rooting for you.